Herbal Medicines for IBS: A Review of the Science

An Overview of Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS)

Herbal medicine in IBS

IBS is a chronic but episodic disorder of the bowels. The most common symptoms include abdominal pain, cramping or bloating, excess gas, mucus is the stool and diarrhea, constipation or alternating bouts of these conditions.  Most commonly, the abdominal discomfort is relieved by passing stool.

Currently, we don’t know the cause of IBS, though it appears to be related to inflammation, “disconnects” between the nervous system surrounding the digestive system (the enteric nervous system, sometimes called the “second brain”), abnormalities in the pattern of the gut flora such as SIBO and dysfunctional muscle contractions in the large intestine. We also know that certain foods, stress and hormonal changes in women can play an important role.

The Rome IV criteria allow for a diagnosis of IBS in people with recurrent abdominal pain that occurs at least once a week during the last 3 months and is associated with two or more of the following:

  • Either increased pain or relief of pain after defecation
  • A change in the frequency of bowel movements
  • A change in the appearance of stool

Treatment of IBS

Mainstream medical treatment of IBS includes dietary approaches such as avoiding certain foods and changing up the amount and types of fermentable carbohydrates in the diet as well as medications to treat diarrhea, constipation, gas or pain. Exercise, biofeedback and therapy to cope with IBS is sometimes recommended as well. Other alternative therapies recommended include stress management, probiotic supplementation and acupuncture.

Unfortunately, a lot of the time conventional treatment approaches don’t work. So doctors and patients need to look outside of these options for other natural alternatives such as herbal medicine.

Digestive disorders have been treated for centuries by herbalists—and the science is still “catching up”.

Below is a look at the herbs which have been proven effective in studies for IBS.

Herbal Medicines for IBS

Peppermint Oil

Peppermint oil for IBS

The most “mainstream” herbal remedy for IBS nearly universally accepted is peppermint oil. Several recent reviews have concluded that peppermint oil is a safe and effective treatment for IBS in both children and adults. 1,2,3,4 

The substances in peppermint oil, primarily menthol, appear to be anti-spasmodic, anti-inflammatory and have anti-bacterial effects. Peppermint oil improves gut motility and decreases the spasms and the associated discomfort of IBS. 5,6 When several studies were analyzed, the percentage of patients who showed improvement in symptoms ranged from 39 to 79%. 7

Artichoke Leaf Extract

Artichoke leaf extract capsules. tablets, and ampoules

Artichoke leaf extract was used in two studies and is included here because the results were promising.  In the first study, a specific extract, Hepar-SL forte, was found to reduce (after 6 weeks) abdominal pain and cramping along with a reduction in bloating, gas and constipation. 8

In another study, artichoke extract (Cynara SL) reduced symptoms by about 26% in patients whose main complaint was indigestion and upset stomach. 9 Another non-randomized study indicated that artichoke leaf could provide a significant reduction in IBS symptoms. 10

Aloe Vera

Alove vera for IBS

Aloe vera has shown some utility in relieving IBS with constipation but had little or no effect on other symptoms, so it would appear to be most useful for IBS with at least some constipation episodes.

A recent review of aloe vera showed somewhat better results, finding that aloe vera improved symptoms for constipation-predominant IBS (IBS-C) safely and effectively. 11 Aloe vera may also be functioning as a source of prebiotics.11

Blond Psyllium (Plantago)

psyllium husks powder for IBS

While there is some contradictory evidence, most studies have shown psyllium to improve some of the symptoms of IBS—particularly constipation, diarrhea and overall abdominal discomfort. A recent study indicated that psyllium can reduce abdominal pain in children with IBS. 12 The most recent meta-analysis of studies on psyllium’s effect on IBS indicates that psyllium, or more generally, soluble fiber, was effective in treating IBS with no evidence of harm. 13

Curcuma longa

Turmeric for IBS

Curcumin, derived from the turmeric plant was studied in an 8-week pilot study in two doses, 72 or 144 mg of a standardized extract. Both groups showed a 53% and a 60% decrease in symptoms respectively, with22-25% reporting a reduction in abdominal pain and discomfort. 14

Herbal Mixtures

Iberogast (STW 5) and STW5-II

Iberogast for IBS (STW5)

Iberogast® (STW 5) contains Iberis (bitter candytuft), angelica root, chamomile, caraway, milk thistle, lemon balm, peppermint, celandine and licorice. Iberogast has been shown to improve symptoms of both functional dyspepsia and IBS. The combination of herbs affects the upper and lower digestive systems to provide significant relief. 15,16 It is not clear which of these herbs have the greatest impact on IBS, but in Europe, this combination is often recommended because of the significant symptom overlap between functional dyspepsia and IBS.16

STW5-II contains iberis, Melissa, licorice, chamomile, peppermint and caraway and showed significant improvement in IBS symptoms and abdominal pain. 17

Padma Lax

Padmalax for IBS

Padma lax is a traditional Tibetan formula which contains aloe, jateorhiza root, marsdenia and rhamnus bark, along with 6 other herbs. In one study, significant improvement in constipation, severity of abdominal pain and gas was seen. Significantly more people reported an improvement as compared to previous treatment(s). 18

Traditional Chinese Medicine Formulations

Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) formulations have also been studied in IBS. Here are the types with positive studies.

TXNG

chinese medicine for IBS

TXNG or Tong-xie-ning, contains peony, atractylodes, citrus rind and allium and was tested in IBS-D.  Results indicated decreased IBS-related pain (as measured by a numeric pain intensity scale), decreased frequency of diarrhea and an improved consistency in stool. 19 Nearly 83% of all patients reported a reduction in pain as compared to about 40% of non-IBS patients.

TXYF

Chinese herbs for IBS

TXYF or Tong-Xie-Yao-Fang contains atractylodes, peony, citrus rind and ledebouriella root and was tested in IBS-D. Patients reported decreased pain.  Lab tests indicated decreases in 5-HT and corticotrophin-releasing factor (CRF), though the significance of these findings is not clear. 20

A recent meta-analysis indicated that a number of TCM formulas performed significantly better than pharmaceuticals in IBS-C. 21

Medical Cannabis

Medical Cannabis for IBS

Medical cannabis has been used for centuries to control pain, nausea and vomiting. The digestive system has numerous endocannabinoids and the tissues of the digestive system have receptors for the endocannabinoids. While research is currently limited, there are abundant anecdotal reports that cannabinoids derived from cannabis, particularly CBD (cannabidiol) can be useful to treat abdominal pain and nausea in IBS.

One study showed that cannabis could significantly reduce abdominal pain in Crohn’s disease. 22 A number of researchers have postulated that IBS, along with fibromyalgia and migraines, may actually represent endocannabinoid deficiency. 23,24 Research into the potentials for the use of medical cannabis is expanding—a recent review of the role of cannabis in digestive disorders concludes that “…the current literature supports the use of marijuana for the treatment of digestive disorders, the clinical efficacy of cannabis and its constituents for various GI disorders remains unclear.”25

Herbs Not Clinically Tested

who should use herbal antibiotics?

There are numerous herbs that have been used traditionally to treat IBS but that have never been clinically tested specifically for the effects on IBS.

These herbs include chamomile (to calm diarrhea); slippery elm (which can add bulk to the stool for those with IBS-D and softening the stool, for those with either IBS-C or IBS-M); anti-inflammatory herbs such as curcumin, ginger and holy basil; carminative herbs (preventing gas formation) including anise, caraway and peppermint(!); and nervines such as skullcap, oats, lemon balm and passionflower, which can help alleviate stress and calm the digestive system.

A note on SIBO

small intestine bacterial overgrowth

SIBO or small intestinal bacterial overgrowth has been shown to be connected to IBS. In SIBO, the small intestine which is normally free of bacteria is over-populated with bacteria or, in the case of methane-dominant SIBO, prokaryotes.  These organisms may be producing methane gas (methane-dominant SIBO) or hydrogen gas (hydrogen-dominant) SIBO.

For both methane and hydrogen dominant SIBO, garlic in the form of allicin has been used along with either purified berberine or herbs that contain berberine (Oregon grape, goldenseal, barberry and goldthread) and oregano oil. Methane-dominant SIBO is more difficult – there are few antibiotics and herbs that can kill off the methane-producing prokaryotes.  Garlic and allicin are somewhat effective as are berberine-containing herbs.  These tend to lose effectiveness over time and should be alternated. An herb that is effective against methane-producing prokaryotes in cattle but has not been tested in humans is perilla frutescens—which, interestingly, is a member of the mint family.

Summary of Herbal Medicines in IBS

Overall, there are several promising herbal treatments for IBS-C, IBS-D and IBS-M. Peppermint oil remains in the vanguard with artichoke leaf extract, psyllium (soluble fiber), curcumin and herbal formulas from TCM and traditional Tibetan medicine. Medical cannabis holds promise as well.

One thing to keep in mind is that there has not been as much scientific research on herbal remedies for IBS so there are definitely new formulations, herbs, and delivery methods that could be of use in the future.

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *